Magical Make an Offer

Magical Make an Offer

Reviews (278)

Overall rating
4.6
Counts per rating level
  • 85% of ratings are 5 stars
  • 10% of ratings are 4 stars
  • 1% of ratings are 3 stars
  • 2% of ratings are 2 stars
  • 3% of ratings are 1 stars
What merchants think

Feedback submitted

Merchants recommend this app for allowing shoppers to make offers on products, which boosts sales and enhances customer engagement. It features customizable offer templates, automatic and manual counteroffer options, and is praised for its ease of use and straightforward setup. The customer support team is noted for being responsive and helpful with customization and troubleshooting.

November 11, 2021

Easy to install and easy to use. Could use a few more native tools to create the email templates. And perhaps create a mechanism for the buyer to easily counter the counter offer, perhaps as an option. Just to keep the lines of communication open after the counter without either party having to directly email. Also an option to require a full shipping address when placing an offer.

Art Wise Premium Posters
United States
20 days using the app
September 15, 2020

I used this app to get offers but it sidesteps the shipping so if accepted, the customer is able to pay without paying for shipping; minimally useful! Also it has spelling errors (counterd, etc.)

The Art of Antiquing
United States
Over 1 year using the app
October 17, 2023

Are you concerned about your products' uncompetitive pricing in the intense world of online commerce? Put yourself at ease! Magical Make an Offer functionality is excellent for just the purpose of giving shoppers bargaining power. Plus, the customer service is top-notch. Stephen patiently worked with me to solve any concerns and ensure the app worked perfectly how I wanted for my store. With this app's superb functionality and the dedicated support team, you can feel confident in improving your store's conversion rate. Don't hesitate a second; install the app now and see the difference it can make and the peace of mind it brings you! 10 stars of 5!

InspiredGrabs.com
United States
19 days using the app
September 16, 2016

Great app!!!! Just installed it yesterday and today already an offer!!!!
Hopefully I was curious because I did not receive any notification or email informing me I have an offer!
It requires however to work on it: manuel email to answer to the offer (I ve just sent a draft) It would be great to automate the after offer! ;)

Sweety Cats Boutique
France
18 days using the app
September 5, 2022

The Make an Offer app has been a very useful tool to communicate with potential buyers. While the odd offer is unrealistic, most offers are worth negotiating with. It would be good to be able to adjust the template ourselves, perhaps that is in there and we just can't find it. I feel the fees are a bit inflated for what it offers. Saying that, it is highly recommended.

Art by Farquhar
Australia
11 months using the app
Magical Apps replied September 8, 2022

Thank you for the kind review and constructive feedback! Our customer support has reached out to better understand your needs if there is anything we can help with with regards to the templates :), or any other questions you may have. There are also some tips on how to best use MaO you may find helpful here: https://make-an-offer-demo-store.myshopify.com/pages/faq

Thanks again and please reach out should you have any questions!

Edited February 13, 2019

Highly recommend this app. Pro. you will get a customer who is ready to buy but looking for a deal. Con. You will never go to sell customer at MSRP price.

Topchoice Electronics
Canada
15 days using the app
Edited July 10, 2024

Preise sind unverschämt teuer, suchen nach einer Alternative!

Echtheitscheck
Germany
About 1 year using the app
August 27, 2020

Just a few offers ...not really sure how I feel about ithad it for a while.........................................................................................................................................

AUCTIONS SPEAK
United States
About 1 year using the app
April 3, 2020

I just started using this app . Great for retaining a client who may have moved on. Would like a call to discuss some items. Overall a great tool thanks for the app .

Cait's
United States
14 days using the app
Magical Apps replied April 9, 2020

Hi!! Thanks for the kind words! We would love to speak with you. I will contact you and set something up - looking forward to it!

Edited May 29, 2018

Very helpful app. Announcing a sale, in this case a Moving Sale, really helped kick up interest - and the Make an Offer sale resulted in much greater sales than a year-end sale. I sell skis, and they come in numerous lengths. The app allowed individuals to make purchases without specifying length, which created extra work to resolve.

2018/5/29: The ability to limit the pop up to certain items has proven very useful. I enable the pop up on clearance items, which helps move them, and don't enable it on current items, which preserves pricing and makes my retailers happy.

Hagan Ski Mountaineering
United States
8 months using the app