Reviews (41)

Overall rating
3.8
Counts per rating level
  • 78% of ratings are 5 stars
  • 5% of ratings are 4 stars
  • 0% of ratings are 3 stars
  • 0% of ratings are 2 stars
  • 17% of ratings are 1 stars
January 12, 2026

This app and company just keeps getting worse. We have been having claims denied for no reason at all. Sometimes tracking clearly shows it was lost, sometimes it shows it was delivered and we have written affidavit from the customer that it was not, or was stolen. Sometimes even delivered to wrong address. In any case, they will find any reason they can to deny your claims.

Customer support is not help at all and will essentially just forward your emails over to the same claims team that denied them. If you reach out to the claims adjusters, they simply tell you "this is staying closed". My last claim she flat out told me that USPS said the delivered it so it's denied. Ok, so why are you advertising that this protects against theft or packages that were misdelivered?

In the month of December alone, we paid this company (UPS Capital, InsureShield, whatever they go by now), over $800, only for them to deny claims. To me, this is blatant fraud and honestly, we are considering legal action and may also have to talk to our bank about reversing that charge. It's not just these two claims, it's happened before and right now the cost does not justify the spotty coverage they are replying.

Our recommendation, seek a different app. You won't be happy with this one (also, the shopify extension/app is extremely buggy and sometimes won't even show you transactions).

Joco Records
United States
Over 4 years using the app
UPS Capital Insurance Agency Inc. replied January 15, 2026

Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback, and we’re genuinely sorry for what you’ve experienced. We understand how frustrating inconsistent claim outcomes and app issues can be, and this is not the experience we aim to deliver. We’ve already put a team on it to investigate both the claim outcomes and the Shopify app issues you mentioned. A team member will reach out directly to collect details and work toward a resolution. We truly appreciate you bringing this to our attention.

April 15, 2024

A solid 5 stars, really good insurance for our orders, it's been around 2months we are using this and also the customer support is great they reply with a day or so

Olfactoryfactoryllc
United States
About 2 months using the app
UPS Capital Insurance Agency Inc. replied April 17, 2024

That’s what we call the brighter side of shipping! We are so glad to hear that you’ve been enjoying the InsureShield app & had a positive experience with our customer success team.

Edited May 5, 2024

I would not recommend this app at all. After using it for 7 months and only submitted 5 claims, they've decided to change my policy and told me that they were going to deduct $50 from every claim refund on top of what they're already charging me and my customers. The most absurd thing I've heard. But luckily, there's plenty of fish in the sea so I found me a much better app on the app store that doesn't have these ridiculous terms. Keep looking, there are way better apps out there than Insure Shield.

Exquisite Designs Home Décor
United States
7 months using the app
January 29, 2024

We really like using the Insure Shield app on shopify to protect our packages. They have been a life saver for our wholesale and retail site. Making a claim is easy & the agents are very responsive.

Beaded Blondes Wholesale
United States
6 months using the app
UPS Capital Insurance Agency Inc. replied January 31, 2024

Thank you for the wonderful review! We prioritize our customer service and easy claims process so it is great to hear that you’ve had a great experience with our app!

Edited December 27, 2023

I submitted my first claim after months and it has taken a month to get a response only asking for the tracking number because their system is not working properly.

Horrible first-time experience.

UPDATE, Yes I mentioned the tracking number above. Why did it take me to email you a month later to get a response that you needed a tracking number?

Aqua Lab Technologies
United States
8 months using the app
UPS Capital Insurance Agency Inc. replied December 27, 2023

Hi Aqua Lab Technologies - we are so sorry to hear about the inconvenience you experienced when filing your first claim with us. After doing some investigation, we identified there was an issue with the first tracking number you provided with your claim. Upon receiving an updated tracking number, your claim was immediately submitted for payment on 12/20.

We hope that clears up any confusion and would be happy to chat more if you have any additional questions or concerns.

July 13, 2023

We have installed it as a test for insurance of our packages while choosing the option to insure packages only if selected, anyway, we have had it for a few weeks and never used the services and they are charging us fees for some reason even if we proved that the charges are based on false data as we haven't used any of the services. Also, it only covers shopify based orders and not any orders that integrate into shopify from other sources.

Montecinos Ethnic
United States
24 days using the app
UPS Capital Insurance Agency Inc. replied July 17, 2023

Thank you for your review. We appreciate you bringing this issue to our attention and we are sorry to hear that your experience was not ideal. A member of our team will reach out to get more details to assist you.

April 26, 2023

It gives us peace of mind to know we can rely on coverage for our precious tea and ceramics while the easy claim process helps take some of the pain away. Our customers are always impressed that a small shop like ours can give large company customer service.

Tea Dealers
United States
Over 1 year using the app
UPS Capital Insurance Agency Inc. replied April 26, 2023

That's what we call the brighter side of shipping! Thank you, Tea Dealers, for the wonderful review. We are happy to hear you had a positive experience with our claims process.

April 28, 2023

As a company that relies on the timely delivery of packages, we are confident in InsureShield's package insurance. Their straightforward claim process and reliable payment of claims ensure that our bottom line will not suffer from any unforeseeable losses. Moreover, the added protection against package theft through their app is a valuable benefit that provides us with peace of mind, and ensures our customers' satisfaction. In short, InsureShield's package insurance is an invaluable product that helps us mitigate risks, protect our business interests, and maintain the highest level of customer service. I can't overstate how highly I recommend this app!

Budget Billiards Supply
United States
Over 1 year using the app
UPS Capital Insurance Agency Inc. replied April 28, 2023

Thank you Budget Billiards Supply for the kind review! We love to hear that you are happy with our customer service and our claims process. Happy shipping!

April 18, 2024

Absolutely love using this app, it's so easy to use and customer support is top notch. Thank you very much.

Charmboxmen
United States
5 months using the app
UPS Capital Insurance Agency Inc. replied April 22, 2024

Hi Charmboxmen,
We’re glad that you’re loving our InsureShield app! Our goal is to provide great customer service to our customers and we are glad to hear that you’re having a great experience with our support team.

January 18, 2024

It is easy to work with this app. However, I was skeptical at the beginning. Now we have quick replies to our queries.

Prolisok
United States
4 months using the app
UPS Capital Insurance Agency Inc. replied January 31, 2024

We are glad that you had a great experience with our app so far! That’s what we call the brighter side of shipping!