Judge.me Product Reviews App

Thank you for your feedback, and we’re sorry the Etsy import experience didn’t meet your expectations. You’re correct that our current Etsy integration imports reviews from one listing per SKU, and rating-only reviews aren’t supported in imports. We understand how this can be limiting for stores that use multiple Etsy listings sharing the same SKU, especially when it affects the total number of reviews displayed.

We reached out privately to explain these limitations and discuss possible workarounds, including attempting a structured manual import using your Etsy export to consolidate reviews where possible. We also shared your case with our Product team so they can evaluate improvements to the integration.

We appreciate you taking the time to raise this, feedback like yours helps us improve the product and better support merchants using Etsy alongside Shopify. If you’d still like help exploring the manual import option, we’d be happy to assist.