We've been using Judge.me since moving to Shopify ~4 months ago. On our old cart platform, we were paying Shopper Approved almost 10x the cost of Judge.me for arguably a lesser service.
The developer has been incredibly responsive to all requests.
Google organic is reporting perfectly.
Thrilled that the developer continues to roll out features and enhancements.
Comparing Judge.me to Yotpo or Shopper Approved is not fair, because those companies don't have responsive customer support.
I am hoping Judge.me will add store-reviews and 3rd party trusted reviews.
I am hoping Judge.me will add a widget with review summaries, for side-panel or homepage display.
I am hoping Judge.me will add social network shares.
Rumor has it these are in the works.
I would choose Judge.me all over again. If you are reading this and you're paying for a $$$$ service, you can say goodbye now. If you can get them to export your reviews.